The “Stage Not Age Tests” referred to by Ed Balls in his Children’s Plan announced in Parliament on 11 December 2007 is an interesting development and will affect every school across the country if his plans come to fruition. His analogy is that it would be absurd for a child taking music lessons and all to sit the same (e.g. level 5 exam at age 11), but he has missed the point I feel.
The Key Stage 2 tests which children take at age 11 (year 6), covers levels 3-5. A child has the ability to obtain a high level 5 or a low level 3 – so there is a huge range of what can be achieved in the same test.
And while it seems like a good idea that children sit the test when they are ready – In reality it will mean substantial new pressures on every school, every parent, and every child in the country. Why? Well because it will bring about even more competition amongst parents in the playground. “Has you child sat the test yet? – mine has and she’s only 7″. Imagine the pressure that parents will now be placed under – and even more pressure for the child.
And what of the schools? Well you can see the league tables now can’t you. While schools have targets now, these are very simple ones – namely to achieve Level 4+ at age 11 (year 6). Educators have the chance to target children over a period of time so that each can achieve their best.
The new targets will probably be annually and like this :
2009 Table for The Primary School
% age 7 and under taking and passing test (as a proportion of the school) – 7%
% age 8 and under taking and passing test (as a proportion of the school) – 17%
% age 9 and under taking and passing test (as a proportion of the school) – 45%
% age 10 and under taking and passing test (as a proportion of the school) – 68%
% age 11 and under taking and passing test (as a proportion of the school) – 76%
And so I can envisage a situation where every schoool is targeted every year across ALL year groups.
The year 2 teacher will be asked to increase the percentage of her 7 years olds who take and pass the test (because she achieved 7% last year). Likewise the year 3 teacher will be asked to try and beat his 17% that he managed last year … and so on.
The new Stage not Age Tests :
More pressure on the whole school for every year group
More pressure on parents to coach their daughter to pass “the test” before little jonny takes his
More targets for every year group – not just Year 2 and Year 6 classes.
More information about the current sats tests are here